Get your cards graded!

Get your cards graded at Nutmeg Games! 


Nutmeg Games has partnered with The Grading Authority (TGA) and we are excited to offer a service you have been asking for: Grading Cards! 


What cards can I get graded? 

We accept Magic: the Gathering, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Digimon, Dragon Ball Super, Sports Cards, and more! If your card isn’t on the list, inquire with us and we can work with TGA on your behalf. 


How do I prepare my submission? 

You can download and fill out your submission form prior to arrival or you can fill it out with us in store. You can either fill it out digitally and email it to us at or you can print it and bring it with you. Make sure all your cards are in sleeves and top loaders for your submission. 


How much does it cost? 

You can use our pricing chart below! 




Base Grading Price 

$25 per card 

Holofoil Label 

$5 per card 

Team Color-Match Label (sports cards) 

$5 per card 

Return Shipping (stay at home!) 

$10 for entire submission 



How often do submissions get shipped out? 

We ship out submissions every Monday.


What advantages do I get by grading with Nutmeg Games? 

We offer a faster turnaround time (approximately 20 days from mailing date) compared to a direct submission. We handle all the shipping to and from our store and work with TGA for you. Just bring in your submission and we will take care of the rest! You also can opt-in for exclusive Nutmeg Games branding on your slab (only available when submitting though us) so you can show off your local game store pride! 


That all sounds amazing! When can I start? 

Right now! Download and fill out a submission form and come see us today!