Nutmeg Games has been proudly buying and selling hundreds of thousands of cards across the world. We have been working diligently to provide our customers with the best experience possible. We are excited to provide top-notch buying services for you! 

 

Below you will find our instructions for using our online Buy List, including how to sell your cards in bulk. If you have any additional questions, please visit our Frequently Asked Questions page, email us at gamemasters@nutmeggames.com, or call us at (860)-799-6704 between the hours of 12pm-7pm. 

 

Please allow up to 24 hours for approval for all cash Buy Lists or large store credit Buy Lists.  

 

Selling Card Singles 

 

Sign in to your https://nutmeggames.com account. Hover over the “Buy List” link on the banner at the top of the page and click "Sell Your Cards."

 

1. Select the card game for which you wish to sell us singles. We currently buy singles for Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering. You may combine singles from both games into one Buy List.

2. Search for the card single(s) you’re selling in the search bar. (For Pokémon, it's easiest to type in the set number).

3. Add the correct cards to the sell cart. Ensure the cards you’ve added to your list match in set, rarity, language, printing, and condition. You can review your cards’ conditions using our Card Conditioning Guide.   

4. Submit the Buy List order using the “Submit” button in the cart. 

 

Once your Buy List is approved, ensure all cards are presented to the Card Slinger in the order of your submission, front to back, and facing the same direction. Remove all sleeves from your cards to expedite the verification process.

 

Selling Bulk 

 

If submitting bulk from multiple card games, ensure the bulk is separated or divided between card games. All cards must be separated by foiling (non-foil, reverse foil, holofoil) and unsleeved. We currently buy bulk for Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering. 

 

We will transfer your bulk into our own boxes when you arrive at the store, but please ensure cards are packaged in a container that avoids excess damage during receiving. This can include, but is not limited to, cardboard card storage boxes, bundles/elite trainer boxes, cardboard storage boxes etc. Do not submit bulk orders in flimsy/dangerous packaging, such as rubber bands, plastic bags, Tupperware bins, etc.

 

Our bulk trade-in rates are here. You do not need to submit a Buy List for bulk.

 

Selling Sealed Product 

 

Nutmeg Games does not purchase sealed product from sources other than official distributors directly authorized by publishers. This ensures chain-of-custody from publishers like Pokémon --> Distributor --> Nutmeg Games --> Customer.  

 

Selling an Entire Collection 

 

For larger/high-value collections that would require additional preparation to receive or purchase, please contact us at gamemasters@nutmeggames.com to work with a Card Slinger directly.

 

Card Conditioning Guide  

 

You can find our Card Conditioning Guide here to help submit your Buy List accurately!